iloveruthlorenzo23/11/2008 13:06:46

Ruth was in the bottom 2 coz they got the number wrong :'( I am so glad she wasnt in the bottom 2 this week!

Report as offensive

a star was born 199221/10/2008 17:05:26

with this perfomace should have been in bottom 2 instead of ruth

colliedug21/10/2008 16:20:31

I think Simon's got a cheek moaning about circus acts is a bit rich since one of his acts in last year's X Factor had clowns and a bouncy castle on the stage.

colliedug21/10/2008 00:02:54

Frangle, if you think Rachel is unmanageable, then I have to say she is in trouble for the competition. I do agree with you that she would be a superb blues singer, but she would also be a great soul singer up there with Aretha. I agree Simon would be the mentor for her eventually because he's not going to stand for any of her nonsense. Dannii is not on her wavelength, but I think Cheryl could do a better job as well. That's all I'm saying here.

ash_xfactorfan20/10/2008 19:11:47

I think she should have sang Beat It

Report as offensive

inthegap20/10/2008 13:20:44

Great effort Girl inspite of the song not being what i would have chosen for you. However, this is really a competition if you challenge potential artists to come out of their comfort zone. You are brave. Keep shining Sweetheart. love you loads Sisxx

Reported as offensive

ash_xfactorfan20/10/2008 12:47:53

Very talented girl and i just want to hear more from her, she hasnt been given the right songs and next week she needs to be amazing. out of 10 it would be 7 out of 10

Report as offensive

frangle19/10/2008 23:55:20

I wanna hear her sing Elkie Brookes!

Report as offensive

frangle19/10/2008 23:54:15

Can't beleive they deleted my post! All I'm saying is I dn't agree with Colliedug. I dn't think Rachael is manageable. Simon as the strongest mentor would have been best mentor for her but I think he gets her style wrong. Blues singer, she would b fab!

Report as offensive

frangle19/10/2008 23:49:38

Steveybluesbaby! Yea man!

Report as offensive