´liz23/11/2008 22:53:56

I thought their performance was cute and likable, but it doesn't really make you go "WOW!!!". And regarding "blueorca's" comment, that they should have looked more sad for this song. I don't agree. I love this song, and I don't believe this is a song about dwelling on the sadness of the world but about changing it & bringing love and hapiness into the world for everyone. A love that you find within yourself. It's about shining a light in the darkness. So I think shiny smiling faces are in place

Report as offensive

pinkypaige30/10/2008 16:19:28

i thought that u are a bit boring

Report as offensive

colliedug20/10/2008 23:32:50

Admittedly they did produce a better performance than the previous week, but I can't agree that they deserved any more than they got. They do not gel as a group, so there's no point flogging a dead horse. Would you seriously buy any album they produce?

ash_xfactorfan20/10/2008 12:33:45

Better then last week, vocally and the song choice was better. we knew these girls couldn't win the show but i belive they deserved another week. out of 10, i would give them a 5half out f 10.

colliedug19/10/2008 20:42:50

Well, I think you could have put your house on Girlband being voted out of the competition as I predicted last week. After this awfully cheesy performance plus the equally terrible performance in the showdown, the public delivered the coup de grace which Simon Cowell should have been big enough to administer. Honestly, if Louis Walsh thinks he was going to get number one hits with these girls, then maybe he should retire.

Report as offensive

spicegirl2319/10/2008 14:33:46

Such a nice performance for my church dinner with live music from the strongest member of the church choir. This is good its just that thousands out there can do that

Report as offensive

blueorca319/10/2008 14:07:28

I don't think it was a great song rendition, such a sad song yet they were all grinning their heads off...a bit of a sadder look on their faces might have been better, def not one for those big over the top grins. Bad move for them as they are not bad as a group.

Reported as offensive

lynxaq19/10/2008 12:40:51

Aweful, cheesey performance. I was behind you girls last week as I thought you where good but this week was weak and you deserved to go out.