Live show 4: Rock week

Rock Week31 Oct 09

Extend your index finger and pinky, stick your tongue out as far as it will go, and saturate your hair with lacquer… you are now set to rock-out… welcome to Rock Week!

First up to impress the judges and the millions watching at home was Joe McElderry, who’d shown us in previous weeks he was happy to sing big ballads, the question we wanted to know tonight was, how would he deal with a rock song? Singing Don’t Stop Believing by Journey, the young South-Shielder proved he isn’t just a one trick pony by getting the show off to a rocking start.

“You’re an absolute star,” said Dannii: “You looked so comfortable up there.”

Louis was equally as impressed: “You absolutely won me over – I believe you’ll be in the final.”

Simon praised Joe’s consistency but questioned the point of the dancers, who swished and swayed in the background.

After a slight wardrobe-malfunction Cheryl composed herself in time to tell her north-east compatriot that he was going all the way to the final.

We then joined Lucie Jones as her dream of becoming a rock star turned into reality, as her onstage character morphed from a teenage daydreamer to bona fide rock queen. Singing the Guns N Roses smash Sweet Child O’ Mine, the Welsh lass was desperate to put in a good performance, and hopefully squeeze some good comments out of Simon after last week’s criticism.

After a barnstorming performance all four judges were tripping over themselves to praise the 18-year-old

Louis was bowled over by Lucie’s transformation and confirmed she could “sing anything”, sentiments echoed by Cheryl who thought Lucie could become a “little Avril Lavigne”.

Simon reminded Lucie that he thought she was “boring” last week, but added: “Tonight I take that back – you gave it 100%.”

Dannii swelled with pride and told her charge: “I’m so proud and happy for you.”

Eager to put the events of last week to bed, we all thought Danyl Johnson would attack his song like a man intent on staying out of the bottom two. However he chose to cull his usual showmanship and razzmatazz in favour of a stripped back rendition of the Aerosmith hit I Don’t Want To Miss A Thing.

His performance received mixed comments from judges, who weren’t particularly sold on the ‘less-is-more’ approach.

Dannii complained the 27-year-old was out of tune and had lost his “mojo”, Louis stated that there was no way Danyl should have been in the bottom two last week but told him: “You need to pick yourself up and get back in the race.”

Cheryl said: “You just don’t do it for me,” whilst Simon defended his finalist claiming Danyl was in a no-win situation. “You are still the best singer in the competition,” he told him.

Next up was the competition’s ‘babe-magnet’ Lloyd Daniels, who took a risk by singing a rocked-up version of Katy Perry’s I Kissed A Girl. With a harem of female dancers grabbing and pulling him every which way, he seemed to having the time of his life.

“That was the most comfortable I have seen you on stage,” Dannii told him.

A stickler for the rules, Louis claimed that Lloyd had “slightly cheated” because he’d picked a pop song instead of a rock one.

After telling Louis to stop being such a pedant, Simon told the 16-year-old it was: “A million times better this week than it was last week.”

Stacey Solomon completed the first half’s performances with a surprisingly beautiful cover of the Keane song, Somewhere Only We Know.

Whilst Louis “wasn’t crazy” about the song choice, Cheryl loved it and urged the Essex girl to put more of her personality into her performances.

“I was more impressed with you walking, than I was with the singing!” Simon exclaimed, before adding: “I thought that was terrific.”

Read Rock around the clock to find out how the remaining acts fared.

Rate this

Thumbs up Thumbs down

81%
thumbs up

205
ratings

Comments 145 comments

Please register or sign in to add comments

If you're not already registered with ITV please click register below.

Sign in Register

xxkaiadxx 03/11/2009 13:59:13

Wat needs to happen is for all the fans of the acts that hav gone to vote for all the others except john and edward... it sounds mean and im sure they're nice guys but they are beating out amazing singers; first miss frank now rachel its actually terrible

Flag as offensive

xxkaiadxx 03/11/2009 13:56:23

after his performance i reckon danyl shudve gone home. Lucie on the other hand was incredible and i reckon she deserves to win XD

Flag as offensive

cooke77 02/11/2009 20:47:38

the judges decision so far since this programme started has only confirmed that the X-Factor is a very big joke, this is not a singing competition, i wonder what this says about this country. they should wipe out all them judges. ITV should PLEASE PLEASE CANCEL THIS SHOW. this show has lost its values, and we wonder why the only thing good that has ever come out of this programme is Leona Lewis. what a waste of TV space

Approved by The X Factor Team

vinylram18 01/11/2009 22:46:29

listen people. x factor is still a great show. so what simon made a mistake tonight. the real crimes are being committed elsewhere. rachel was far better singer than lloyd (why didn'y cheryll put ethan or dominic in her category??). but are olly (mr personality), joe (horrible withering end to his voice), john and ed (the laugh), stacey (miss personality) or lucy (cant hit the high notes)any better thn rachel also,NO!. its clear that danyl is the best singer. he's the only 1 with any real talent

Flag as offensive

simoncowellbottledit 01/11/2009 21:18:52

Never thought i would say this but Simon Cowell bottled it tonight..he has always said the final two will be judged on the last performance and nothing else...he has betrayed the values of the show for the first time since it started...could it be a political vote or maybe because its easy to see he has a "soft" spot for Cheryl...what ever the reason he knows deep down on that last performance Rachel was by far the best singer.Vote with the remote control as we will and dont watch the show again

Flag as offensive

legalsparrow 01/11/2009 21:13:58

Either the show is a fix or I need to think about emigrating to somewhere where people have taste. The twins cannot sing. Their on stage antics are cringe worthy. Yet another good singer has gone tonight when we all know it should have been those two. The only reason I am still watching is Jamie.

Approved by The X Factor Team

frankophilegu 01/11/2009 21:10:14

Simon's cowardly act tonight has reduced the average quality of the acts on this year's X-Factor from the already risibly low standard. He should be legally banned from having any connection with music ever again. He should also take Louis to one side and persuade him to sacrifice John and Edward for Rachel.

Approved by The X Factor Team

coreyj09 01/11/2009 21:08:21

John and Edward are ruining this show. If they wer'nt here then it would be a different competition. Every week another good singer and performer goes home and these two twins that cannot sing are making a mockery of the show. They may be nice guys but this show is about the ability to sing and perform and every week someone else is losing out to these two twins and they are completely changing the programme and are completely changing the competition

Approved by The X Factor Team

arniecz 01/11/2009 21:05:50

Ok.... enoughs enough. Stop going to the public vote. All four sitting on that bench are professionals, and should be able to make some sort of decision - Simon - that was a disgrace - you are the one who keeps on saying that it's about the performance on the night, and that this is a talent competition. That was a complete cop out.... lets either change the rules (one for Louis) and have it so we remove the "deadlock" or just take it to the straight public vote, top to bottom

Flag as offensive

bimbotuffboots 01/11/2009 20:45:03

oh my god i cant believe i have just seen john and edward go through again.thats it x factor you have just lost yourself another viewer.

Flag as offensive
 
View all Live show 4 content

Related content

Latest

Jedward's last stand

Watch John and Edward's final performance.. 

You Are Not Alone

The finalists perform their charity single

Sponsored by