Live Results 5: The Results - The X Factor - Video

Live Results 5 : Who's made the cut?

Live Results 5: The Results08 Nov 09

The lines are closed and the judges have voted. The act going home tonight is...

Rate this

14%
thumbs up

3134
ratings

Comments 1790 comments

The comments are now closed

Comments for this series of the X Factor are now closed

Thank you for all your posts, thoughts and support and we hope to see you for the next series.

louisewalker12 30/11/2009 21:45:41

disgraceful, it cant be seen as a singing competition any more boooooooooooooooooooo simon, ruining a young girls possible career, absolutely shocking, lucie could have went all the way

chronai1 29/11/2009 21:20:06

Having just watched the results, and being an avid fan,I must say how shocked and disappointed I was with olly's response to being selected for next week. Yes we know he was nervous, but so was LLoyd. Olly could have at least went over and shown some sort of support or commisseration for LLoyd. Instead he just shook his fist in celebration, and walked off. Shame on you olly.

Approved by The X Factor Team

nicolababesx 29/11/2009 18:01:55

aw lucy i was so gutted when you got put out i voted so many times for you hun.aw don,t give up on ur dream ur a great singer i think u should continue ur dream.i'm such a big fan.:):) keep ur chin up xx

lisa millington 24/11/2009 17:11:00

I think its stupid how simon has been saying how rubish jedward are through the whole show and then when it gets to them and lucie in the bottom he does it to dead lock and he new that the twins would get through so it is less competition for the over 25s to go out i think that lucie should come back in the competition or they should take simon of the x-factor cause all he thinks about is his group and not the good people in the competition the twins should not of got passed lucie She way better

lisa millington 24/11/2009 17:04:10

richsmith 21/11/2009 17:05:02

Does anyone know who the dancers are with Jamie Afro in Rocks they r hot ?

byte 18/11/2009 18:30:05

Totally rubbish. The talented ones went! This shouldnt be a singing competition!!

Approved by The X Factor Team

jelly9 17/11/2009 14:07:18

Sooo glad she went never liked her she was staying the same every week soo glad that John and Edward stayed hope they get to the final :D x

Approved by The X Factor Team

carlomagno 16/11/2009 20:31:15

has anyone else noticed that when it goes to deadlock, whoever is on the left hand side of Dermot goes!!!! if we have noticed....have the judges!!!???

iluvexfactor 16/11/2009 19:04:30

John and Edward are the worst form of singers i have ever seen in my life everyone else in that competition deserve to be there apart from those two. what form of talent do they have? i feel sorry for contestants that had to leave, they were the ones with talent that i would consider purchasing from my local music store its a fix!

staceybrannigan 15/11/2009 21:54:15

totally ridiculous!

xpixelisedx 15/11/2009 21:08:47

this is such a joke, John and Edward don't deserve to be there.

shawnieex3 15/11/2009 21:02:59

This is gettin ridiculous now. Why are John nd Edward still in the competition and Jamie and lucie went out. I think its a fix. I just cant get over it. It really does annoy me. It is a singing competion even Dani said its the best singers bad luck. I am sending this comment on behalf of my daughter.

mattyruislip 15/11/2009 20:56:24

Jamie Going home!!!!! What on earth is happening here.

shawnieex3 15/11/2009 20:52:12

I can't belive Lucie was in the bottom two with John and Edward.I think they are rubbish and it is a fix to get more money and publicity. It is suppost to be a music competion and they can not sing. My Daughter stormed out the living room in a mood. She cant stand listening to them trying to sing.

m.c.k.w 15/11/2009 13:51:06

Boycotted Xfactor this week ! I cant stand watching this show anymore, the whole show is fake. Simon's comments on previous shows about how this is a 'singing competiton' have all been eradicated by his decisions this week, all he wants is more publicity for the show which he knows Jedward bring. He says that he would rather see Jedward perform again rather than Lucie, but Im guessing that he'd rather hear Lucie on the radio !.

Approved by The X Factor Team

byte 14/11/2009 23:17:19

I used to respect Simon's opinions until last week. Again, this week he tried to win the public favour by what he said. I dont vote because I dont believe in Xfactor esp. knowing how much it is raking in from public votes. Keep pursuing your dream Lucie. You have the talent and voice.

tiegan c 14/11/2009 21:18:30

I think John and Edward deserved to go through even though Lucie is great I think John and Edward will win because they are so amazingly Rubbish but there funny so thats why the pubblic vote for them.

corbybhoy 14/11/2009 19:52:49

Linney1983, Lucie may well not be as good as Leona and Alex, in your opinion. But this year neither of these two are in the competition. Lucie was good enough to win it and Cowell knew it. Thats why he did what he did. How nieve some of you are. You are playing a part in the Simon Cowell show. Its all for him, its all about him. He gets richer as he plays you. Enjoy being played! Vote Jedward.

xfarce09 14/11/2009 19:39:22

Thank you LinnyCowell for your comment. If only life were so simple, so black and White? How easy to say change the channel. You are asking 12 million PLUS people to change the channel? LOL do you know what % of the viewers that is? Sorry, but figures themselves show how popular a program this is and how much money comes from those viewers. Stop comparing to past contestants too, you sound like Louie!

Approved by The X Factor Team

View all Live Results 5 content