Judges muse over Series 6 - The X Factor - Detail

Videos

Judges muse over Series 613 Aug 09

Simon, Louis, Dannii and Cheryl share their thoughts for the first time on the new series and give us an insight into what they are looking for...

Rate this

91%
thumbs up

290
ratings

Comments 21 comments

The comments are now closed

Comments for this series of the X Factor are now closed

Thank you for all your posts, thoughts and support and we hope to see you for the next series.

tiggertigger77 28/11/2009 13:23:38

While judges, when they are not obsessed with the way they look, often stick to their own subjective preferences. Last year Simon went personal about Daniel, down to being rude. While this year Louis who voted off Jamie for seemingly personal dislikes and in favour of Lloyd, one week later suggested that Lloyd shouldn’t be there because of his not that strong voice. Such ‘change of heart’ honestly makes pretty little sense. If it is an objective competition to find a true singing talent, then su

Flag as offensive

tiggertigger77 28/11/2009 13:22:48

It seems that the show is lacking objectivity... Given how much internet preferences result (that is seemingly the fair representation of the public likes) differ from the official vote, I believe that if people were given an opportunity to vote only once , the show may have had a different flow. So, the people that go through may not be what genuinely public thinks, but how many times they are keen to call to support their favourites.

Flag as offensive

stormybabe 09/11/2009 09:15:00

What is going on with the judges? why week after week is Simon taking it to the public vote? why does it always have to be Simon who is asked last to make the final decision? What is the point of having the judges there at all if they are not prepared to make the final decision 'fairly' of who goes and who stays.I used to like simon for his honesty and forthrightness, but it seems he is listening far to much to those who slate him for that honesty and is losing his touch.

Flag as offensive

button 01/11/2009 18:12:09

Simon is by far the best judge on X factor,he knows what he is talking about, Dannii is ok,Louis is 15 years behind the times,he has no idea and Cheryl is by far the worse judge on x factor.I never understood how she was picked in the first place,what experience does she have, 26 and in a girlie band! This year she really has shown her true self,some of her comments are spiteful!She doesn't care about talent it's about her winning,she and Louis need replacing,so many better judges out there.

Approved by The X Factor Team

maxlala 31/10/2009 22:08:46

This competition has become a competition amongst the judges, and they are costing talenteed artists a lot, e.g Danyl Johnson is a very talented man. I acknowledge that at the end of the day it is the viewers' choice but they are influenced by the judges' comments, and Cheryl's comments towards Danyl are not constructive. All she said about his performance tonight was that He just didnt do it for her........ Is this about sex appeal or its a musical talent.

Flag as offensive

abizzel 26/10/2009 16:32:07

cheryl cole is by far the best judge they have had on this show look how good her girls were last year...she real..sincere...and honest...i would even say she is better than simon..she makes better choices and piks better songs...when simoin had the boys last year he was useless...he had one of the best boy singer austin!! and let him down....and anyone sayin dannii minouge is the best judge is blind deaf and stupid she is awfull...her girls thus year are weak compared to last year not beautiful

Flag as offensive

janeflux 25/10/2009 20:48:07

Tonight's performance 25th October...get rid of Cheryl Cole and her hypocrisy in outfits and her naive and useless judging...the Twin Boys are terrible and they certainly did not sing BIG BAND SONG last night...Simon Cowell is the best Judge for his honest feedback and what is going on that Cheryl's cole's little boy got through and Miss Frank/Danyl now have to sing off...ITS BECOMING AN ABSOLUTE JOKE and FARCE!!!!...Keep Simon Cowell and Louise..Danni and Cheryl RUBBISH! SAME WORDS as USUAL.

Approved by The X Factor Team

danniiroxlorenzo4eva 15/10/2009 21:13:24

Dannii is the best judge by far!!!! LUCIE TO WIN!!!!! GO DANNII!!!!!!!!!

Flag as offensive

pinkshoes 05/09/2009 22:21:11

I LOVE Dannii, she is the best judge and is absolutely beautiful.Love ya Dannii : )

Flag as offensive

sparker123 22/08/2009 21:17:58

wowow simon cow man man cute

Flag as offensive

Older