hawkeye200824/11/2008 16:09:19

Yes, i noticed that Diana and Eoghan had alot of help from overly loud music and backing singers (the oldest trick in the book for professional singers) But this is supposed to be a show searching for an outstanding act, not an act who needs help covering up flaws in their performance.

Report as offensive

shelly0623/11/2008 18:06:15

Im sorry but diana and eoghan were rubbish their big notes were covered by the backing singers they cheated the public because they cant sing those songs they both should be gone not rachel or daniel they were much better than diana and eoghan i cant stand them.

dianavickers2win200823/11/2008 12:03:22

faldo67 i think you right (Y) jls should have gone, sorry to say it, at the begining of the competition they said you have to send home someone based on there last preformance (the sing off) and rachel was better, sorry x DIANA 2 WIN !

Report as offensive

paige_xfactor23/11/2008 11:51:41

yey, finally rachels gone!! GO JLS

Report as offensive

gaia22/11/2008 23:53:28

Wow! Can't believe Rachel's out. Can't believe Rachel and JLS were in bottom two when mediocre Ruth is still in. Ah well, it's only a TV show!

Report as offensive

trampledunderfoot22/11/2008 23:28:50

*Simon

Report as offensive

trampledunderfoot22/11/2008 23:24:27

HOW ON EARTH is Diana still here? Are people really that tone-deaf? How is she getting praise from the judges and all these celebrities? The only thing that makes her different is the fact that she can't sing. She wails. Her recording voice is awful too. I don't get it. Louis made the right decision. Rachel's voice sounds like a foghorn. Wish her all the best though.

roz2422/11/2008 23:00:24

I think JLS would have done Rule the World much better than Rachel did. I hope next week they tell Luis where to go and do their own thing. I think they were much better in their very first audition than they are now, and thats all Luis fault. They need to bring back that charm and impeccable vocals. (btw in my opinion they should try and sing the song they sang in their first audition... LOVED IT!)

Report as offensive

david }{ diana2win22/11/2008 22:48:36

i've never really been a big rachel fan, but her survival song was spectacular and she should not have gone.

Report as offensive

faldo6722/11/2008 22:48:20

I have to say that earlier I said Rachel needed some vocal coaching and having heard her in the sing off, I believe she has had them. The vote off is suppossed to be based on the best singer/s in the sing off and Rachel blew JLS out of the water. Yes she has been in the bottom 2 3 times now, but I think its more to do with the public not warming too her. Hats off to her she pulled it out of the bad tonight and JLS should have gone home, Simon you called it wrong tonight...

Report as offensive