dreamboy8101/01/2009 21:32:44

By the way, saying that the most successful singers (Britney on top of them) can't sing and should learn from Beyoncé or else is really banal. Again, avoiding to belt out DOESN'T MEAN not being able to sing. On the contrary, those who don't oversing are often the only ones who can TRULY convey feelings and emotions. Praise to Britney and those who use their voices in an original and meaningful way.

Reported as offensive

dreamboy8101/01/2009 21:22:15

Sorry, but I don't find anything special in this video. Beyoncé and Alexandra have two very similar voices, which are themselves very similar to many other R&B/pop voices out there. And actually I find it very sad that everybody mentions artists like Beyoncé (or Christina or Leona, for that matter) as the only singers who can sing. How can everybody be so superficial to think that singing only means being loud? As if it meant always expressing something, which is what singing should be about...

Report as offensive

godofthunder2427/12/2008 16:01:50

Consider this ... "Listen" was written for and partly by Beyonce. Who do you think would sing this song better? Consider this also ... Beyonce has 10 years of performing at the top level plus a one in a million voice. I think those who consider Alex to have won on the back of Beyonce's performance might have a point but really Alex held her own under great pressure and given time I'm sure will establish herself has a successful artist.

xsim2x25/12/2008 19:14:46

she won this cos she has a very gs voice not cos she sung with beyonce... luv u loads alexandra!!!!!!!!!! xxxxxxxxxxxxx

mimi32122/12/2008 19:56:46

i think the duet was very good, B is not the best singer but singing with Alexander she sure sounded good in fact B highlighted the fact that Alexander is not a good singer. B is very conceited she must of practiced that performance often to get 1 over Simon for dissing her talent in the past. actually good songs r better than good voices, the most successful singers cant sing. B sure won that round.

wikid20/12/2008 11:08:42

Alex won cos of this performance. Not cos it was outstanding or anything, but Beyonce has a HUGE fanbase.

geordiegiirl15/12/2008 22:46:38

Love it love it love it! How many singers can hold their own in a duet with Beyonce singing a Beyonce song?!?! They are both amazing and I would love to see them record something together! Go Alex you're a star!!

elle.oxox15/12/2008 19:43:00

wow Alex and Beyonce was amazin it made me have guce bumps.xoxo

raymc15/12/2008 17:40:20

Oh my! Beyonce what a superb lady. Humble, brilliiant, generous and beautiful. Loved it, well done Alex!

sand16415/12/2008 16:51:17

Beyonce is a super star and Alex is a born super star please hear the public voice and release the duet single i will definately get it, It was a magic moment to see those young ladies sing together......